Pages

Sunday, November 30, 2014

America's Land Ethic

Until I read Schneider's interview with George Davis, I hadn't thought much about how the American land ethic compared to others around the world. It was pretty disheartening to find that, in Davis' experience, America is unique for its primarily economic view of nature. He says "I think everywhere I've gone, with the possible exception of the area we're working in China, the people have a much more sincere and deep respect for the land and water resources than we have here in the Adirondacks and elsewhere in country" (Schneider 314). I was even more interested to learn about Davis' thoughts for why this is. I found myself agreeing most with his point about the abundance of the land. As a culture, we don't feel tied to the land we settle on because we can so easily relocate. The United States is a vast country and, from a geologic standpoint, we've barely begun to tap its natural resources. For many, it is hard to feel tied to the land when there is so much if it, so readily available. This respect for the land is something Davis thinks will develop as our culture does, but I shudder to think of the extent to which we will have to destroy the land until we begin to appreciate it.

1 comment:

  1. It is amazing how much we can ignore the culture of others, and live with the mindset that the way we do things is the right or 'normal' way. In this case, we are definitely not doing it right. I agree with both post of Davis' that you note here, and I think there is one more to consider. Right now, the land feels vast and abundant, allowing Americans to belittle their destruction of the land with the idea that there will always be more. As vast as it seems, this land is a finite resource, and we have the ability to destroy it. Yes, over time, our culture and history will develop to a place where we can begin to hold a substantial land ethic, but another factor affecting our appreciation of the land will be the visible decrease in resources that we will have at our disposal.

    ReplyDelete