St. Lawrence County is
located in the northern part of New York State, on the outskirts of the
Adirondacks Park. Although it's not directly in the park, the controversy
regarding this topic can often be seen in the park too. Using the land and the
rivers has generated jobs in this region for hundreds of years. Currently, in
St. Lawrence County, there is a proposal for the creation of a whitewater kayak
park on the Grasse and Raquette rivers, in hopes of boosting the economy. As people attempt to weigh the benefits
on the local economy and the potentially negative impact on the environment, this
proposal has sparked a controversial debate.
Whitewater paddler in Potsdam, NY. http://www.northcountrypublicradio.org/news/story/30966/20160212/could-a-whitewater-park-lift-all-boats-in-st-lawrence-county |
Creating a
world-class, whitewater kayak park will have a huge impact on the local economy
of the St. Lawrence County region. The project will produce a controlled
release from the Colton dam and will provide ideal conditions for the annual
white water paddlers at Stone Valley. Scott Shipley, a former Olympic kayaker
and engineer for the project, estimated that the whitewater park could bring up
to $3.4 million in tourist spending every year. With the park you’ll get
festivals, competitions, and build the local brand of being an outdoor and
whitewater destination, where people well choose to go vacation at. There will
be tourism money brought in from kayakers and those traveling to watch participants
in the competitions.
Despite the
economic benefits, it’s important to take into consideration the environmental
impact. The proposed project involves building brand-new whitewater attractions
in Canton and Potsdam. The project will alter the flow of river by carving out
bedrock and moving boulders. It will add boat launches, trails, and parking
lots to the surrounding regions. All of these actions will impact the local
ecosystems.
The struggle to balance the
economic benefits and environmental impacts is constantly occurring in the
Adirondacks. Locals living in the park often struggle financially, work multiple
jobs, and rely on the summer tourism to bring money into the park. However,
tourism can come at an environmental cost to the park. It is difficult to
determine what is right and what is wrong, as the lines are often blurred.
Sources:
http://www.northcountrypublicradio.org/news/story/30966/20160212/could-a-whitewater-park-lift-all-boats-in-st-lawrence-county
http://www.watertowndailytimes.com/dco/canton-residents-hear-possiblities-of-st-lawrence-whitewater-park-project-20160210
I think this is a really interesting moral dilemma for the citizens of St. Lawrence County. Economically, it seems like a no-brainer to create the whitewater kayak park that will undoubtedly bring much needed money to the area. On the other hand, the environmental impacts are big and must be considered as well. I wonder if there's a way to alter the current plans to decrease the potential environmental damage. It will be very interesting to see what they decide to do.
ReplyDelete